Smart Ass Take:
Tired of your old Cynicism? Sure, it came free with your first doomscroll, and yes, it makes you look smart (spoiler: looking smart and being smart are not the same thing). But longtime Cynicism users report side effects including lower pay, worse health, fewer promotions, and a baffling inability to spot actual liars (the one job Cynicism promised to do!).
Now there is something much better than Cynicism: Introducing the new and improved Hopeful Skepticism! All the critical thinking of your old model, now with the radical assumption that the guy who cut you off in traffic is probably not a supervillain, just late for his kid’s recital. It asks questions instead of filing lawsuits! It checks the evidence instead of cherry-picking it! Early Hopeful Skepticism adopters report more money, better health, and occasional pleasant conversations with strangers at the grocery store. And best of all, it is completely FREE!! Hopeful Skepticism easily replaces your tired, old Cynicism. Try it out today!
Article Excerpt:
“Cynicism is a form of naiveté. Assuming that nobody can be trusted and just looking for evidence that you’re right — that’s a great way to convince yourself that you’re smart and a terrible way to actually learn about the world and other people.”
Article Summary:
Cynicism is having a moment. Americans trust each other less than they used to, and Stanford psychologist Jamil Zaki calls it “an utterly understandable response” to the world. Understandable, sure. Accurate and helpful? Not so much. Research links cynicism to worse physical and mental health, missed opportunities, and a lower likelihood of voting, protesting, or doing anything about the problems that made you cynical in the first place.
Then there’s the “cynical genius illusion,” coined by psychologist Olga Stavrova. People assume cynics are sharper, but her data from 200,000 people across 30 countries found cynics scored lower on reading, math, science and computer literacy. Cynics also earn less, become leaders less often, and are worse at detecting lies. Zaki puts it bluntly: “If it were a pill, cynicism’s warning label would be three feet long.” Great for feeling smart, terrible for actually learning anything.
The alternative is “hopeful skepticism”: approach the world like a scientist, not a lawyer, starting from an assumption of positive intent. A global study found nearly 70 percent of people cooperated with strangers for the common good at a personal cost, yet guessed only 47 percent of others would. The news and social media warp our sense of what regular people are like, which is why we despise humanity in general while liking our actual neighbors.
The fix, if you want it (cynics mostly don’t): fact-check your assumptions about people, talk to strangers more than your instincts suggest, practice “positive gossip” by sharing stories of others’ kindness, and cultivate hope. Apparently pictures of babies and tree saplings help. Who knew.
Read the Full Article
🌱 Try This
This week, run one of your cynical assumptions through the lab instead of the courtroom. Treat it like a hypothesis, not a verdict.
- Pick one specific person you’ve quietly decided is selfish, lazy, or up to something, like the coworker who never answers emails or the neighbor with the gas-powered blower.
- Write down exactly what you expect will happen if you actually talk to them.
- Have a real conversation with them, and ask at least one question you don’t already think you know the answer to.
- Compare the result to your prediction, and be honest about which one was closer to the truth.
Get the best of Sevenelles in your inbox. Free, no ads, one click to leave.
Subscribe